Thursday, January 19, 2012

Piaget vs Vygotsky

Piaget and Vygotsky's theories are very different from one another, other than the fact they are both about a child's development. I explained Piaget's stages in the previous blog, and so I will explain Vygotsky's theory quickly.
Vygotsky assumes there is a developmental trajectory, where everything we learn is connected, like a movie. He also assumes that our cognitive skills are structured through language, our social relationships and culture are very important, and learning is situated and collaborative. Vygotsky believes there is a zone of proximal development in which the material taught is beyond what the student can do himself or herself. The other big point in this theory is one of scaffolding, in which the teacher supports the student so they can continue to grow and learn.

If asked to choose which theorist resonates more with my personal inclinations, I could not. Piaget's stages are very observable; it is simple to see which stage a child is in and therefore helpful to know what to expect from the child in their learning. However, the ages of these stages are difficult to actually list, because each child develops at his or her own rate. Both theorists discuss the child's development, but Piaget leans towards how the child interacts with the physical environment, where Vygotsky is all about the relationships. Relationships and social interaction is crucial for a child's development, and I believe that student-teacher relationship will help the child succeed. The concept of scaffolding is excellent, and I think that teachers should definitely provide students with this, and it is done through the social relationships.

I find that the one large difference between the two theorists is that Piaget gives an outline of where the child is in their development whereas Vygotsky actually explains how the child progresses and develops, and how the teacher plays a role in that. I suppose it is because of that reason that I begin to lean towards Vygotsky.

No comments:

Post a Comment